AGNSY
Agnsy Insights

Buying a Home in the Bay Area: The Insider's Guide

How do you win a Bay Area home without overpaying? A broker on offer deadlines, disclosures, lenders, contingencies and the 3% deposit.

How do I pick a mortgage lender in the Bay Area?

Buying a home in the Bay Area starts with the lender. Pick yours before you pick the home, and make it one the listing agent can get on the phone. When your offer comes in, the listing agent calls your loan officer to ask how solid you are, and a local lender who picks up on a Sunday beats an 800 number.

Ask for a fully underwritten pre-approval. A pre-qualification is a guess based on what you told them, while an underwritten pre-approval means someone already went through your tax returns, pay stubs and bank statements. That's what lets you write an offer with no loan contingency later.

Most Bay Area buyers at our price points need a jumbo loan. In Santa Clara, San Mateo, San Francisco and Alameda counties a loan over $1,249,125 is a jumbo in 20261, so on a $2 million home with 20% down you're borrowing $1.6 million and you're well past it. Jumbo rates change from lender to lender and so does how they count RSUs, so ask about both on the first call.

Is an all-cash offer better?

Cash wins because it's certain and fast. There's no lender who can say no, no appraisal, and it can close in a week or two. A UC San Diego study of about 2 million home sales found cash buyers paid about 10% less than buyers with a mortgage2, which is what certainty is worth to a seller.

But you don't need cash to compete with cash. A buyer with an underwritten loan, no contingencies and a short close looks close to the same to a seller, and that's how our clients with a mortgage win. If you do have the cash, you can pay cash to win and put a loan on the home after you close.

What is an offer deadline in the Bay Area?

It's the day the listing agent collects every offer at once, and agents also call it the offer date. A home goes on the MLS, where homes get listed, there are a week or ten days of showings with two weekends of open houses, and then offers are due on a set date. It's built to make buyers bid against each other without seeing the other offers.

The deadline is the seller's tool and not a rule. A seller can take an offer before the date, which is called a preemptive offer, unless the listing says they won't look at any. And when a deadline passes with no offers, the leverage moves to you. I negotiated $620,000 off a $5 million Los Altos Hills home that had sat for 31 days.

Can you trust the listing agent?

We believe what's in writing and verify the rest. The listing agent works for the seller, and their job is to get the seller the most money on the best terms. California law does require them to deal honestly with you and to tell you what they know that affects the home's value 3, but "we're expecting a lot of offers" is a sales pitch.

So I ask questions with answers I can check. How many offers are in hand right now? I don't ask how many disclosure packages went out, since twenty people can download the disclosures and three will write. What does the seller want besides price? Is there a number they've already turned down?

How do I read a disclosure package?

Read it before you write the offer, because in the Bay Area that's when you get it. California requires the seller to disclose what they know about the home 4, and sellers here go further by paying for the inspections upfront. Every buyer gets the same disclosure package with the home inspection, the pest report, often a roof report, the seller's own disclosure forms and the title report. It's the reason buyers here can skip their own inspection contingency, since the inspections are already done.

The package can run hundreds of pages and a short list of things matter. Start with the pest report, where Section 1 is damage that's there today with a price to fix each item. Then the foundation, drainage and roof pages of the home inspection. Then the seller's answers about leaks, work done without permits and disputes with neighbors. Then the natural hazard report, because a fire or flood zone decides what your insurance costs, so get an insurance quote before you offer.

How do I figure out what a Bay Area home is worth?

Ignore the list price and look at what sold. List prices here are often set low on purpose to bring in more buyers and more offers, so a home listed at $2.5 million can be a $2.9 million home and every agent at the open house knows it.

The price comes from the comps, which are the last few months of sales in the same neighborhood and the same school boundaries, adjusted for lot size, condition and where the home sits on the street. Price per square foot gets you close and the rest is judgment. Then set your number before the deadline. The right number is the one where you'd be fine losing the home to someone who paid more.

How do I win a bidding war without the highest price?

Terms are how you win without being the highest price. The big ones are how fast you close, how much you put down as a deposit, whether the seller can stay in the home after closing (a rent-back), and which contingencies you keep. So find out what the seller needs. A seller who is buying their next home might take less money for a few weeks of free rent-back, and it works the other way too. On that Los Altos Hills deal we let the sellers win on terms, with a rent-back, no contingencies and a quick close, so we could win on price.

Should I waive contingencies?

Contingencies make you weak. A contingency is your way out of the contract if the loan, the appraisal or the inspection goes wrong, and California's standard purchase contract gives you 17 days on each by default5. To a seller that's 17 days where you can walk and take your deposit with you. In our experience the offer that wins a multiple-offer situation is usually non-contingent, which means it has none.

But you earn the right to waive them before you offer. You can drop the loan contingency because your loan is already underwritten, the inspection contingency because you read the disclosures, and the appraisal contingency because you have the cash to cover the appraisal gap, which is the difference when the home appraises under your price and the lender lends on the lower number.

Then know what's at risk. Once you're in contract with no contingencies, backing out can cost you your deposit. The deposit, also called earnest money, is typically 3% of the price and due within 3 business days, and California law treats up to 3% as a valid amount for the seller to keep on a home you plan to live in6. On a $2 million home that's $60,000.

What is escrow and how long does it take in California?

Escrow is a neutral third party that holds the money and the paperwork until both sides have done what the contract says7. In Northern California it's usually the title company. Your deposit goes there, your lender sends the loan there, the seller signs the deed there, and once everything is in, the deed is recorded with the county and you get the keys.

With a loan, escrow usually takes 21 to 30 days, and with cash it can be 7 to 14. The length is written into your offer, so it's one more term to negotiate. Before you wire anything, call your escrow officer at a number you already have and confirm the wire instructions. Scammers send fake ones that look exactly like the real thing.

Can I use my credit cards during escrow?

Use them like you always do and don't open anything new. Your lender can pull your credit again just before closing 8, and a car loan, a furniture store card or a big balance for appliances can change your numbers enough to delay the loan or kill it. Buy the couch after you have the keys.

Same goes for your job and your bank accounts. Don't switch employers, don't move large amounts between accounts without telling your loan officer, and don't co-sign for anyone.

Can I change lenders during escrow?

Yes, since nothing ties you to a lender until you sign the loan documents, but the closing date in your contract doesn't move. A new lender means a new application, new paperwork and sometimes a new appraisal, and you have to get your final loan numbers at least three business days before you sign9. If you waived your loan contingency and the new lender runs late, the seller doesn't have to give you more time, and your deposit is at risk.

The better move is to take the other lender's written Loan Estimate to your current loan officer and ask them to match it.

How should a married couple take title in California?

Escrow will send you a form asking how you want to hold title, which is called vesting, and your escrow officer can't give you legal advice on which box to check. We're brokers and not attorneys, so this is the one question we send out. It's worth a call to an estate attorney or a CPA, because the answer changes taxes and inheritance.

California is a community property state, so a home a married couple buys during the marriage generally belongs to both. The choices you'll see are community property, community property with right of survivorship, joint tenancy, or your living trust if you have one. California created community property with right of survivorship for spouses, and it passes the home to the surviving spouse without probate10. Joint tenancy does that too, but the two can be taxed differently when one spouse dies, and that's the part to ask the CPA about.

If only one of you is going on title, expect escrow to ask the other spouse to sign a deed giving up their interest.

Who pays the buyer's agent?

In our experience the seller still does. On 9 of our last 10 Bay Area deals this year the seller paid the buyer's agent commission at 2.50%. No law sets that number and it's always negotiable. We give our clients 85% of our commission back, which on a $3 million home at 2.5% is $63,750.

If you're buying in the Bay Area, book a 15-minute discovery call.

That AL Homes page ranks on wording, not authority. Its title is word for word the first “People also ask” question, and “buying a home in the Bay Area” is in its opening sentence and three of its seven subheads. A photographer’s 2020 blog sits above Zillow on the same page, so a small site can win this search.